|
Alternative
power sources sought for remote bases
By Breanne Wagner
April 2007—Mobile generators that produce renewable energy
are about to be fielded by the Army’s Rapid Equipping Force in Iraq
and Afghanistan.
Available from commercial suppliers, these technologies not only offer low-cost
power, but may also cut the number of petroleum tanker convoys traveling
dangerous roads in Southwest Asia.
While hybrid vehicle technology and fuel cell programs are still in research
and development, new, more mature programs such as wind and solar powered
generators are being touted as quick, mobile power solutions by the Army’s
Rapid Equipping Force.
U.S. commanders in Iraq have asked the Pentagon to come up with portable
renewable energy sources, possibly in the form of wind turbines and solar
power. They are seeking ways to cut back on the number of ground convoys
that transport fuel into Iraq.
The director of the Rapid Equipping Force, Col. Greg Tubbs, asked a group
of energy experts to find commercial products that can be deployable within
18 months and that will reduce fuel consumption by 40 percent.
“We want to do nothing to diminish mission capability, but rather
decrease the fuel need,” Dan Nolan, head of the effort at the REF,
said at an Institute for Defense and Government Advancement tactical power
conference.
The U.S. military relies heavily on fossil fuel. The Defense Energy Supply
Center said the military brought in a total of 1.29 million gallons of fuel
per day in Iraq. From Kuwait alone, U.S. troops bring in 890,000 gallons
of fuel a day across the southern border, Nolan told National Defense.
This massive fuel need became a dangerous liability when insurgents began
targeting convoys coming from Kuwait, Jordan and Turkey. The result was an
increase in improvised explosive device attacks against them. Attacks were
as high as 30 per week.
“There has always been strategic importance on reducing dependence
on energy we don’t control … but now there is a tactical importance,” Nolan
asserted.
The REF task force is focused on developing solutions for forward operating
bases, or places where the U.S. military does not plan on having a permanent
presence, Nolan said. This created a need to find small, transportable devices.
Skybuilt Power of Arlington, Va., is providing
a mobile power station, which has been dubbed the transportable hybrid
electric power station. The THEPS uses several different power sources,
including a wind turbine, solar panels, a diesel generator and storage
batteries. The system’s diesel generator
uses “as little fuel as possible” while decreasing the logistical
tail from fuel run Systems, Skybuilt Power CEO Dave Muchow, told National
Defense.
THEPS provides, on average, 5 kilowatts of power output, depending on the
type of units and the weather conditions, Nolan said.
The system can fit into a standard freight
container. Muchow believes that it can “put power closest to the source,” he said. “Mobile
power Systems can more easily get to remote areas where roads are blocked.”
Skybuilt will make two variants for the Army,
one mobile power station that can be towed by a humvee, and one tactical
operations center that can act as a “manned or unmanned operations center, a medical clinic, small
office or sleeping quarters,” Muchow said. “It can be heated,
air conditioned, outfitted with sensors.”
The first THEPS system was scheduled for shipment to REF headquarters at
Fort Belvoir, Va. in March, where it was to undergo a 45-day testing schedule.
The REF is considering shipping units to Djibouti and Kuwait and then to
Iraq and Afghanistan.
A so-called “tactical bio-refinery” is another mobile system
being pursued to convert field waste to energy. The system, which is built
by Defense Life Sciences, McLean, Va., will convert paper, plastic, cardboard
and food slop into bio-fuel gas to power a 60 kilowatt generator, Nolan said.
The food waste goes into a bioreactor, where industrial yeast ferments it
into ethanol, a “green fuel,” according to Purdue University,
whose scientists are working with Defense Life Sciences. As an added benefit,
the system helps to eliminate much of the waste on the battlefield.
The bio-refinery can save 115 gallons of fuel for every ton of waste converted,
Nolan said. The first prototype has already been built and the full system
will be ready for demonstration within 12 months, said Jerry Warner, founder
of Defense Life Sciences.
On this project, the REF worked with the Defense Advanced Research Projects
Agency.
Under a separate effort, DARPA is developing a mobile integrated sustainable
energy system, or MISER. The idea is to take packaging materials — not
garbage — from the field and convert them to generator fuel, which
could eventually be used in a fuel cell.
Packaging materials account for a large amount of field waste — more
than seven pounds per day per soldier. DARPA aims to reduce the cost and
logistical burden of disposing the plastic packaging by harvesting it for
energy.
The high-energy content of the plastic packaging — close to that of
diesel fuel — makes it an ideal alternative energy source. “At
today’s level of packaging being discarded, a military unit could achieve
well over 100 percent self-sufficiency for its generator fuel needs,” according
to a DARPA document.
The REF is also pursuing in-house technologies to solve some of the power
issues in the field. One example is the intelligent generator set, which
is being developed by the Army’s communications-electronics research
development and engineering center. It will act as a back-up power source
for renewable energy source Systems. The small 3 kilowatt tactical quiet
generator can power hybrid Systems at night or at times when there isn’t
a lot of wind or sun, said a researcher at the Army Research Development
and Engineering Command, who asked not to be identified.
When the Army requires the extra help, the generator will use only 0.4 gallons
of fuel per hour when running at full 3 kilowatt power, the researcher added.
The generator will soon “be able to communicate through a central
distribution set when to turn on and off,” Nolan said. Currently, a
soldier has to manually turn a generator on or off, which can waste energy.
Plans call for future versions to be able to operate and communicate within
an intelligent power distribution set.
Two of these generator sets have been ordered and received. An additional
system will be delivered to Fort Belvoir for field support and trouble-shooting
purposes, Nolan said.
Other sustainable power solutions such as hybrid electric vehicles and hydrogen
fuel cells — two of the most well known and publicized alternative
power sources — are still being funded and developed to reduce fuel
dependency. Yet the focus has shifted away from these Systems.
Col. Don Gibson, director for integration at the Army Research, Development
and Engineering Command, found that fuel cells and hybrid electric vehicles
may not save the military as much energy as once hoped. Slower development
also means that they will not be a viable solution to the urgent fuel convoy
problem.
Gibson concluded that fuel cells are “inadequately ruggedized for
the military environment,” and that “significant fuel savings
are not likely.”
Fuel cells have also been criticized as being too expensive and too new
for military use.
However, fuel cells as part of a hybrid system are considered to be a viable
option for the future. Gibson believes that fuel cells will first be used
in small, portable Systems.
Hybrid electric vehicles are also touted as an innovative power solution,
but development has slowed in recent years as a result of the complexity
of adapting the technology to the rugged military environment. While the
commercial market has made great strides in development of hybrid vehicles,
it’s not so easy for the military.
Gibson said that “fuel savings are unproven” in hybrid electric
military vehicles. These vehicles also require extensive military driving
cycles and scenarios “to facilitate efficient and reliable system design
with reasonable and predictable life.”
There is still a lot of work to be done if these vehicles are to become
a viable alternative power source. Analysts estimate that at the earliest,
military hybrid vehicles could enter production in 2010.
Please email your comments to BWagner@ndia.org
* * * * *
2500 Wilson Blvd., Suite 215, Arlington, VA 22201
Phone: 703.276.7592 | Toll-Free: 866.786.2845 | Fax: 703.276.1697 |